
Ponche is a warm tropical-fruit punch. As I mentioned in my previous
post — thank you for all the wonderful comments! — it’s traditionally
imbibed in Mexico during Christmastime. Vendors sell it at night near
the sidewalk Christmas markets. It’s also served with buñuelos during
the
posadas.
No one seems to know exactly how and why Mexican ponche materialized. In general, historians seem to agree that
the punch concept originated in India,
where English sailors took a liking to it and brought to Europe. The
Spaniards (or the French?) must have carried the tradition to Mexico.
Today, the base of Mexican ponche comprises
piloncillo,
a dark-brown unrefined cane sugar, mixed with water and cinnamon
sticks. To that, you can add pretty much any winter fruits you want:
apples, oranges, guavas, tejocotes.
The latter two are key.
Tejocotes
are small, speckled orange fruits with an apple-pear taste, and their
soft flesh turns almost creamy while soaking in the ponche.
Guavas lend just the right amount of tang and citrusy perfume. The
smell of guavas cooking with cinnamon and sugar is intoxicating. Someday
someone’s going to make a million dollars selling it to Williams-Sonoma
as an air freshener.

The ponche workhorses: tejocotes (small orange fruits in front), guavas (left), apples and cinnamon
In addition to the fresh fruit, ponche can contain prunes, raisins,
tamarind, walnuts. Some folks add hibiscus flowers, which gives the
ponche a pretty burgundy color.
Ponche isn’t an exact science. Everything simmers together until the
fruit is tender, and the dried fruits become plump, sugar-swollen
nuggets. If you are like me, you will hover over the pan and give
yourself a ponche facial, letting that sweet, spicy steam envelope your
face.
You can’t see the steam in the picture below, but that’s because I
was so smitten once the ponche started to cook that I forgot about my
camera, and kept fishing raisins and tamarind pieces out of the pot to
eat.

Ponche simmering on the stove
Ponche has a lot of ingredients, but it requires minimal chopping. If
you have a helper the whole thing can be on the stove within 20
minutes.
If you like — and we do, in our house — a little nip of brandy, rum
or tequila, feel free to add it in. Just make sure to serve the cups
with a spoon, so everyone can dig into their boozy (or not) fruits.
Recipe below.
Ponche
Adapted from
Fany Gerson’s My Sweet Mexico
Makes about 3 1/2 quarts
Note: You shouldn’t feel wedded to any ponche
recipe, as the ratios can be tweaked for your specific tastes. Fany’s
version includes tamarind, raisins and prunes, but I found the original
quantities to be a little too tangy, so I lessened them and added more
water. In the future I may leave out the prunes all together.
If you don’t have piloncillo, you can substitute brown sugar. If you can’t find sugar cane, just leave it out.
The amount of water depends on how thick you like your ponche. Once
the fruit starts to cook, the mixture will thicken — feel free to add
more water to thin it out. Ponche also reheats beautifully on the stove,
thinned with a little water. It will keep in the fridge in an air-tight
container for at least a week.
To cut piloncillo: Grab the thick end of cone and
slice with a knife. It’ll require some force on your end, but it should
work. (The piloncillo should not be so hard that you can’t cut it.) You
could also try scraping it along a box grater. Don’t put the cone in the
food processor, or it might break your machine.
Ingredients
2 1/2 to 3 quarts water* (see note)
2 cinnamon sticks, about 6 inches long
8 ounces tejocotes, left whole
6 guavas, peeled and cut into bite-sized pieces
2 mild-flavored apples (not Granny Smith), peeled, cored and cut into bite-size pieces
2 four-inch pieces of sugar cane, peeled and cut into thin strips
1/2 cup pitted prunes, halved lengthwise
1/2 cup dark raisins
5 long tamarind pods, peeled and seeded, or three tablespoons of tamarind pulp without seeds
6 to 8 ounces piloncillo or dark brown sugar (this equals about one average cone)
Rum, brandy or tequila (optional)
Directions
Bring water and cinnamon sticks to a boil in a large pot. Add the
tejocotes and lower the flame. Cook over a slow, rolling boil until the
tejocotes are soft, about five minutes.
Remove the fruit from the pot, let cool and then peel the skin off
with your fingers. (It should come off easily.) Cut the tejocotes in
half, and remove and discard the seeds.
Once they’ve been peeled and de-seeded, place the tejocotes back into
your pot of cinnamon-water and add the remaining ponche ingredients.
Stir to combine and let simmer for at least 30 minutes. If you’re adding
alcohol, pour it into the pot right before serving time.
To serve the ponche, remove the cinnamon sticks and ladle directly
into mugs, making sure to include the chunks of cooked fruit. The strips
of sugar cane can be served directly into the cup, to suck on after
you’re finished drinking.